1
Poetry / Re: Analysis and Synthesis: I Grew Up & The Urban Indian
« on: November 28, 2009, 10:32:58 pm »
Both of the narrators in "The Urban Indian" and "I Grew Up" are native people. They used to live in their native reserves, but now they may left there. In "The Urban Indian", we directly know it, but we can know that the speaker in "I Grew Up" also left his reserve inderectly. In the refrain "I grew up thinking/ 'i'm never going/ to leave this place'", the speaker only tells that he thought he would live there forever, but the tone suggests that he probably left the reserve now.
However, the attitudes of the narrators in "I Grew Up" and "The Urban Indian" toward their reserves are a little different. The speaker in "I Grew Up" liked his reserve not only for giving him his identity, but he loved the nature, the people, and everything there in the reserve. He was "a child who would lie under trees"(line8-9) and "a child who ran wild rhythms through the fields"(line 23-25), "eating berries/ cupping cool water to [his] wild stained mouth"(line 28-30). However, the narrator in "The Urban Indian" chooses to live as a citzen of a big city Toronto, since he already got used to the comfortable city life. He doesnt like the mosquitoes, the natures anymore. (Perhaps he still likes them, but he does avoid them at first!)
The tone in "I Grew Up" is rather more sentimental, or nostalgic, since the speaker misses his reserves. However, the narrator in "The Urban Indian" accepts his "civic status" and keeps enjoying his life as a citizen of Toronto.
Um,,, Please tell me if i misunderstood,, so that i can fix them.. haha thanks
However, the attitudes of the narrators in "I Grew Up" and "The Urban Indian" toward their reserves are a little different. The speaker in "I Grew Up" liked his reserve not only for giving him his identity, but he loved the nature, the people, and everything there in the reserve. He was "a child who would lie under trees"(line8-9) and "a child who ran wild rhythms through the fields"(line 23-25), "eating berries/ cupping cool water to [his] wild stained mouth"(line 28-30). However, the narrator in "The Urban Indian" chooses to live as a citzen of a big city Toronto, since he already got used to the comfortable city life. He doesnt like the mosquitoes, the natures anymore. (Perhaps he still likes them, but he does avoid them at first!)
The tone in "I Grew Up" is rather more sentimental, or nostalgic, since the speaker misses his reserves. However, the narrator in "The Urban Indian" accepts his "civic status" and keeps enjoying his life as a citizen of Toronto.
Um,,, Please tell me if i misunderstood,, so that i can fix them.. haha thanks
